Key takeaways
- The carrier decides. On insurance work, the platform is set by the carrier or TPA handling the claim, not the contractor.
- Xactimate is the market leader for U.S. property claims. Symbility is used by a smaller group of carriers and is more common in Canada.
- Both use line-item estimating with regional pricing, but their pricing databases, sketch tools and workflows differ.
- Don't simply "convert" an estimate. Rebuild the scope in the required platform so the pricing and line items match what the reviewer expects.
The quick answer
Xactimate and Symbility are both professional software platforms for estimating property damage repairs on insurance claims. Xactimate is made by Xactware, a Verisk company. Symbility is owned by CoreLogic. Both produce detailed, line-item estimates priced with regional labor and material costs.
The biggest practical difference for contractors is not a feature. It's who uses each one. Most U.S. insurance carriers review claims in Xactimate, so it's the default for most roofing and restoration work. Some carriers and third-party administrators (TPAs) run their claims programs on Symbility instead. When you work one of their claims, your estimate is expected to match.
If you're new to this world, you may want to start with our complete guide, What Is Xactimate?, then come back here for the comparison.
What is Xactimate?
Xactimate is a claims-estimating program developed by Xactware, which is part of Verisk. Adjusters, contractors and restoration companies use it to build repair estimates from a large database of standardized line items. Each line item is priced for the loss location using regional price lists that are updated regularly.
Xactimate is available as a desktop application and an online version. It includes Sketch, a drawing tool that calculates square footage, wall areas and roof surfaces from a floor plan or roof diagram. Estimates are usually shared as .ESX files that another Xactimate user can open and review line by line.
Because so many carriers use Xactimate, adjusters across the country can review an Xactimate estimate quickly. Contractors also benefit from writing in the same "language" the adjuster speaks. For a deeper walkthrough, read What Is Xactimate? The Complete Guide.
What is Symbility?
Symbility is a cloud-based claims platform owned by CoreLogic. Its estimating tools, often referred to as Symbility Claims Connect and Symbility Mobile Claims, let adjusters and contractors build repair estimates, draw room and roof diagrams, attach photos and share files inside one connected system.
Symbility was designed around collaboration. The carrier, adjuster and contractor all work on the same claim file in the platform, rather than emailing files back and forth. Pricing comes from CoreLogic's regional cost data, and carriers can configure the platform to match their own guidelines.
Symbility has a strong presence in Canada and is used by a number of U.S. carriers, TPAs and managed repair programs. It's less common than Xactimate on U.S. residential claims, but when a carrier uses it, contractors in that carrier's network are usually expected to estimate in it.
Symbility vs Xactimate: side-by-side comparison
| Category | Xactimate | Symbility |
|---|---|---|
| Owner | Xactware (Verisk) | CoreLogic |
| U.S. market position | Market leader for property claims | Smaller share; used by specific carriers, TPAs and programs |
| Deployment | Desktop and online versions | Cloud-based, browser and mobile |
| Pricing data | Xactware regional price lists, updated regularly | CoreLogic regional cost data; carrier-configurable |
| Sketching | Xactimate Sketch (floor plans, roofs, elevations) | Built-in diagram tools, mobile-friendly |
| File sharing | .ESX files and XactAnalysis assignments | Shared claim file inside the platform |
| Learning resources | Large training ecosystem and certification levels | Vendor training; smaller community |
| Who chooses it | Usually the carrier | Usually the carrier |
| Best for | Most U.S. insurance repair work | Claims from carriers or programs that require Symbility |
Features and packaging change over time. Check with Verisk and CoreLogic for current product details and licensing.
The key differences explained
1. Who decides which platform you use
This is the difference that matters most. On a typical insurance claim, the carrier or its TPA decides the platform. If the adjuster's estimate came from Xactimate, the carrier will expect your scope in Xactimate. If the claim was assigned through a Symbility-based program, the carrier will expect Symbility.
You can usually tell by looking at the adjuster's estimate. Xactimate estimates have a familiar layout with category codes (such as RFG for roofing or DRY for drywall), and the file is often shared as an ESX. Symbility estimates have a different layout and usually reference the Symbility or CoreLogic platform.
2. Pricing data
Both platforms price line items by region, but they use different pricing databases. Xactimate uses Xactware's price lists, which are researched by region and updated over time. Symbility uses CoreLogic's cost data, and carriers can configure pricing settings for their programs.
As a result, the same repair can price differently in each platform. That's one reason a contractor's Xactimate total and a carrier's Symbility total may not match, even when the scope is identical. When you compare estimates across platforms, compare the scope (items and quantities) first, then the pricing.
3. Line items and estimate structure
Both tools build estimates from standardized line items organized by room or area. The naming, codes and groupings are different. A line item that exists in Xactimate might be split into two items in Symbility, or bundled differently, and the reverse also happens.
This is why "converting" an estimate line by line often goes wrong. A correct estimate in the second platform needs to be rebuilt using that platform's items, so nothing is double-counted or left off.
4. Sketching and measurements
Xactimate Sketch is one of the program's strongest features. It lets estimators draw detailed floor plans, roof planes and elevations, and the quantities flow directly into the estimate. Symbility's diagram tools are built for speed and mobile use, so field adjusters can capture rooms on a tablet during an inspection.
Both platforms can work with aerial roof measurement reports. How those reports are imported depends on the integration and the carrier's setup.
5. Workflow and collaboration
Xactimate work usually moves through XactAnalysis, Verisk's assignment and claims-management system. Carriers send assignments, contractors and adjusters upload estimates, and the carrier reviews them. Files can also be shared directly as ESX files.
Symbility was built around a shared claim file. Everyone works in the same cloud record, which can make communication with the carrier faster. However, it also means you need access to the carrier's program to collaborate fully.
6. Learning curve and support
Xactimate has a large training ecosystem: official courses, certification levels, user groups, and many experienced estimators and trainers. Because it's so widely used, it's easier to find help or hire someone who already knows it.
Symbility is generally considered intuitive, especially on mobile, but there are fewer experienced users in the contractor community. Contractors who only occasionally work Symbility claims often find it inefficient to stay fluent in both.
7. Cost and licensing
Both platforms are paid software. Xactimate is offered through subscription plans for contractors and other users. Access to Symbility is often tied to a carrier program or a direct license from CoreLogic. Pricing changes, so check with each vendor directly. Don't forget to include training time and the cost of mistakes while you learn.
Many contractors avoid the cost entirely by outsourcing to an estimating company. To compare options, see Xactimate for Contractors: buy, hire or outsource?
Have a claim in Symbility or Xactimate? We write both, with the same documentation and the same 24–48 hour turnaround.
Request an EstimatePros and cons of each platform
Xactimate
Pros
- Used by most U.S. property carriers
- Powerful, detailed Sketch tool
- Large line-item database
- Big training and support community
- ESX files are easy to share and review
Cons
- Steep learning curve for beginners
- Ongoing subscription cost
- Easy to miss items without experience
- Desktop version needs a capable computer
Symbility
Pros
- Cloud-based, so you can work from anywhere
- Strong mobile tools for field inspections
- Shared claim file improves collaboration
- Carriers can configure it to their guidelines
Cons
- Used by fewer U.S. carriers
- Smaller pool of experienced estimators
- Access often depends on carrier programs
- Pricing differs from Xactimate, which can confuse comparisons
Which one should contractors use?
For most U.S. contractors, the answer depends on who your carriers are:
- You work mostly retail and standard insurance claims: Xactimate covers the vast majority of your work. Start there.
- You're in a carrier program or TPA network that uses Symbility: you'll need Symbility for those claims, and probably Xactimate for everything else.
- You only see a Symbility claim occasionally: outsourcing those files is usually cheaper than buying and learning a second platform.
- You work in Canada: Symbility is more common there, but Xactimate is also widely used. Check with your main carriers.
Whichever platform you use, the quality of the estimate depends on the estimator. That means complete line items, correct quantities, documented code requirements and clear photos. Good software can't make up for a missing scope.
Tips for writing estimates in either platform
- Match the carrier's platform and price list. Use the same platform as the adjuster's estimate, and the price list for the loss location and date.
- Compare scope before price. When your number differs from the adjuster's, find the missing or different line items first.
- Rebuild, don't translate. When moving a scope between platforms, rebuild it with native line items.
- Document every item. Every line should be supported by a photo, a measurement, a code reference or a note.
- Don't forget the "hidden" items. Steep and high charges, detach & reset, code upgrades, debris removal, permits and O&P are among the most frequently missed.
- Keep sketches accurate. Wrong dimensions throw off every quantity that depends on them.
Common mistakes to avoid
- Sending a spreadsheet or a lump-sum bid when the carrier expects a line-item estimate
- Using an outdated price list or the wrong region
- Comparing Xactimate and Symbility totals without comparing scope
- Copying line items one-for-one between platforms
- Leaving out photos that support the more expensive line items
Frequently asked questions
Is Symbility better than Xactimate?
Neither is better in every situation. Xactimate is used on the majority of U.S. property claims, while Symbility is required by a smaller group of carriers and TPAs. The best platform is the one the carrier on your claim uses.
Can I submit an Xactimate estimate on a Symbility claim?
Sometimes, but it's risky. Many Symbility carriers expect estimates in their own platform and pricing. A mismatched format can slow down review, or the adjuster may rebuild your scope themselves.
Who decides whether a claim uses Xactimate or Symbility?
In almost every case, the insurance carrier or its third-party administrator decides, based on the claims platform it uses.
Do I need both licenses?
Most contractors only need Xactimate. If you regularly work for Symbility carriers, you can license it too or outsource your Symbility estimates to a service that writes in both.
Why is my Xactimate total different from the carrier's Symbility total?
The two platforms use different pricing databases and line-item structures. Compare scope and quantities first. Then look at pricing differences.
The bottom line
Xactimate and Symbility are both capable estimating platforms. For contractors, the right one is usually the one your carrier uses. Xactimate covers most U.S. claims, so it should be your starting point. Symbility matters when you work with carriers and programs that require it.
If you'd rather not license, learn and maintain two platforms, Estimation Experts USA writes carrier-ready estimates in both. Learn more about our Xactimate estimating services and Symbility estimating services, or check our pricing.